The Z List
The Z List - This Week's Biggest Losers 05/19/07

Paul HaggisGeorge Lopez lost a bunch of money this week because of Geico, whose cavemen characters helped nudge him off the ABC-TV grid. At least Lopez made it to the promised land of syndication; others in the annual network TV upfront derby weren't so lucky.


Paul Haggis: On the film side, Haggis, who shares his hometown of London, Ontario with hottie couple Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams -- is used to making history. He's the only screenwriter responsible for back-to-back Best Pictures ("Million Dollar Baby" and "Crash"). But on the small screen, his much ballyhooed NBC drama "The Black Donnelly's" is simply ... history. Maybe Haggis should have taken the hint when the network relegated an eighth episode, "God is a Comedian," to the realm of iTunes because it was deemed too violent. Squeezed in between "The Departed" and "The Sopranos," this story of four brothers in an Irish mob family wound up not having the luck of their brethren.


Donald LogueDonald Logue: It's never a good sign when a sitcom's working titles were way funnier than the one they eventually used. Who knows? If ABC's "Knights of Prosperity" had stuck with either "I Want to Rob Jeff Goldblum" or "Let's Rob Mick Jagger," it might not have been grounded for life. But Logue was a sport about it all, jumping onto the IMDB bulletin boards before the upfronts, giving fans the scoop and putting in his two cents about the context of his cancellation. "We opened against a bowl game (Notre Dame LSU) and did well," he wrote of his show's critically acclaimed first episode. "The next week we were pre-empted by George Bush assuring the U.S. public that 25,000 more troops were going to be asked to give up their lives by getting between Sunnis and Shias who have been fighting for 1300 years..."


Andy RichterAndy Richter: Conan's former sidekick just cannot catch a break in primetime. With NBC chopping "Andy Barker P.I.," he's got another one to add a trash heap, which includes "Quintuplets" and "Andy Richter Controls the Universe." What really stings in this case is that Conan co-created the show with Richter and threw all of his weight behind it at the Television Critics Association Winter Press Tour. "I feel like this is the best primetime work I have ever done," said Richter at the time. But when Richter saw that NBC was willing to put all six episodes up on the Internet before they had aired, it must have felt about as good as reading the reviews for his Olsen twins flick "New York Minute."


Michael Rapaport Michael Rapaport: Always a fun guest on "The Best Damn Sports Show Period," this guy's sitcom "The War at Home" was moved around willy-nilly for two years by Fox, eventually winding up in the death slot of 7:30 PM Sundays. And even though Rapaport has another TV pilot cooking over at CBS called "Fugly," he still sounded pissed when he sent out a pre-emptive MySpace bulletin last weekend, confirming the cancellation of his family comedy. It was definitely in-your-face entertainment ala "Married with Children," but one suspects that if Simon Cowell had been cast as the nosy neighbor, it would have survived.


Aaron Sorkin Aaron Sorkin: In the sketch show, coin-flip sweepstakes, Sorkin's low-rated "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip" lost out on Monday to the scandal-plagued "30 Rock." Sorkin fans everywhere are still in mourning, bemoaning the fact that a new bionic woman has been favored by the Peacock over unabashedly adult entertainment. But after a hiatus revamp failed to win viewers with more romance, this very expensive failure will now get to play out the string on Thursdays. Still, Sorkin has what no others in TV land have: the ability to cry all the way to the Tom Hanks-Julia Roberts-Mike Nichols bank (the stars and director of the upcoming Sorkin-scripted feature film, "Charlie Wilson's War").

Filed under: The Z List


Tags: aaron sorkin, AaronSorkin, andy richter, AndyRichter, Conan Obrian, ConanObrian, donald logue, DonaldLogue, michael rapaport, MichaelRapaport, paul higgis, PaulHiggis, studio 60, Studio60

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 2) | 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. if this guy aint HIGH i dont know who is!!!

oh yeah-- an FIRST! for the FIRST time ever!!

Posted at 1:22AM on May 20th 2007 by U LOOK SOO F*D UP

2. You guys couldn't be more wrong about Haggis. The Black Donnellys did not fail because it was a horrible show. It was so amazing and if you took the time to actually sit down and watch all of it (which is on NBC.com), you would know that! The Black Donnellys failed because it wasn't advertised enough and it was in a horrible time slot. Think about it, Studio 60 and The Real Wedding Crashers were both in the same time slot and they got cancelled too. What does that tell you? The time slot was one of the things that did it. I'm just hoping that another network sees what NBC couldn't. That The Black Donnellys is one of the most amazing shows on TV and should be on TV for years to come. Haggis is amazing and in no way did anything wrong by making this incredible show!

Posted at 11:17AM on May 20th 2007 by Nikki Allen

3. the Black Donnellys had to be the best drama on tv.

Posted at 1:02PM on May 20th 2007 by laurie

4. The Black Donnllys is the best show to hit network television in a long time. And then to have it replaced by a reality show is an insult to NBC viewers. NBC did not give this show a chance to survive. They did not promote it well and then put it in a known failure of a time slot. This show has a lot of supportive fans that are doing everything in their power to get this show back.

Posted at 3:22PM on May 20th 2007 by Stefanie

5. The Black Donnellys was the best thing that has happened in television. The demise of the show (though hopefully not permanently) was all due to the disastrous decisions that NBC has been making. All of their other shows have done so much worse. Haggis is not to blame. It's the network. The show has a huge fan following despite the fact that the show had practically no media promotion. I personally want to thank Paul Haggis for giving us some real television, and now, something worthwhile to fight for! The show is smart, witty, emotionally wrenching, passionate.... the writing, acting, and directing are all superb.

I mean, NBC put Heroes in hiatus in the middle of the season, and then lost a huge chunk of fans when they finally decided to bring it back. Whose fault was that? Why do you think that NBC is in fourth place? It certainly isn't due to a single show!

Posted at 7:31PM on May 20th 2007 by crose

6. You're so WRONG. The Black Donnellys is a great , GREAT, show. Its my belief one that the show wasn't given enough time to take root. I also think the show is a victim of "reality-nomics". Reality-nomics is the word I've coined for cheap networks that don't want to pay for real actors on real tv shows. Instead, they offer a small amount of prize money (compared to the production costs of a great drama like TBD) to watch a group of "real" people make idiots of themselves. Americans seem to love watching the misery and cut-throat behavior of people.

I hope Haggis, along with the actors of TBD shop around and get the show picked up. It will be a rain maker for someone. Please do some research before you slam a cancelled show. It doesn't always mean its a bad show, sometimes it means the network heads made a BAD decision.

Posted at 10:05PM on May 20th 2007 by Ernest Phillips

7. First of all, "God Is A Comedian" was the 3rd episode of "The Black Donnellys" (no apostrophe, the name is not possessive). Had you actually watched the show, you would know that. It's NBC that should be on the Z-List for screwing up "The Black Donnellys" because it was great, it was just very badly promoted and went up against CSI: Miami AND the NCAA playoffs. It also had a nauseating 2-hour Deal or No Deal lead-in for its 3rd-7th episodes.

Posted at 9:20AM on May 21st 2007 by Tommy

8. The biggest loser of the week was not Paul Haggis...it was NBC. Hopefully, Mr. Haggis will continue this superb drama on another network. There are tons of fans out there waiting to find out what happens to the Donnelly brothers.

Posted at 9:50AM on May 21st 2007 by mija71

9. The Black Donnellys is an amazing show and deserved much better treatment than it received from NBC. If you haven't seen it, do yourself a favor and watch the episodes. They are all available at nbc.com or can be downloaded from itunes. Bashing Paul Haggis for mistakes made by others is not right.

Posted at 11:01AM on May 21st 2007 by SHaun

10. Paul Haggis did an outstanding job on The Black Donnellys. It was NBC that bombed out, not Paul or his show. TBD is the best new show on tv, bar none. If the show was given a fair chance I have no doubts that it would build a fan base, it honestly just needed some time and some promotion.

SCREW THE CHEERLEADER................SAVE THE BLACK DONNELLYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 11:39AM on May 21st 2007 by Moe

11. The Black Donnellys was the most AMAZING show on TV!!!! It makes me really upset that NBC pulled it, I still religously watch the episodes online. I REALLY REALLY hope that someone picks it up for next season.

Posted at 12:37PM on May 21st 2007 by Jessica

12. OMG! You are sooo wrong! The Black Donnellys is the best show out there and NBC had to screw themselves out of it! But why should we be surprised....NBC has a habit of giving good shows the ax! If it weren't for a couple of shows (ER and hmmm...can't think of any other)...I wouldn't even turn on NBC.

Posted at 2:42PM on May 21st 2007 by Kimberhaze

13. Paul Haggis is a very talented man and just because NBC was too dumb, deaf or blind to realize that doesn't mean he's a loser. The Black Donnellys was one of the best shows to ever be on network TV. What does that say about us as a society when we'd rather watch game shows and reality TV than an intelligent, well written drama. NBC puts all its stock in Heroes which is already starting to loose viewers. Then they try to throw some ignorant crap like "The Real Wedding Crashers" and "Thank God You're Here" at us and hope that we're dumbed down enough not to realize. No thank-you! NBC has lost a viewer in me.

Posted at 7:38PM on May 21st 2007 by Majesty21w

14. _The Black Donnellys_ was brilliantly written, directed, and acted -- a concept carried out with the utmost of excellence. Paul Haggis is the greatest screenwriter since the late, great Robert Bolt went into eternity.

(In this dramatist's humble opinion)

Posted at 11:59PM on May 21st 2007 by CountessofBuchan

15. You could not be more incorrect on this one. NBC screwed up once again by cancelling such an amazing show. The Black Donnelly's deserved more of a chance than they were given. This show absolutely would have gained a fan base if it were given a real chance. NBC dropped the ball on this one.

Posted at 7:39AM on May 22nd 2007 by Natalie

| 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments