The Z List
The Z List - This Week's Biggest Losers 05/19/07

Paul HaggisGeorge Lopez lost a bunch of money this week because of Geico, whose cavemen characters helped nudge him off the ABC-TV grid. At least Lopez made it to the promised land of syndication; others in the annual network TV upfront derby weren't so lucky.


Paul Haggis: On the film side, Haggis, who shares his hometown of London, Ontario with hottie couple Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams -- is used to making history. He's the only screenwriter responsible for back-to-back Best Pictures ("Million Dollar Baby" and "Crash"). But on the small screen, his much ballyhooed NBC drama "The Black Donnelly's" is simply ... history. Maybe Haggis should have taken the hint when the network relegated an eighth episode, "God is a Comedian," to the realm of iTunes because it was deemed too violent. Squeezed in between "The Departed" and "The Sopranos," this story of four brothers in an Irish mob family wound up not having the luck of their brethren.


Donald LogueDonald Logue: It's never a good sign when a sitcom's working titles were way funnier than the one they eventually used. Who knows? If ABC's "Knights of Prosperity" had stuck with either "I Want to Rob Jeff Goldblum" or "Let's Rob Mick Jagger," it might not have been grounded for life. But Logue was a sport about it all, jumping onto the IMDB bulletin boards before the upfronts, giving fans the scoop and putting in his two cents about the context of his cancellation. "We opened against a bowl game (Notre Dame LSU) and did well," he wrote of his show's critically acclaimed first episode. "The next week we were pre-empted by George Bush assuring the U.S. public that 25,000 more troops were going to be asked to give up their lives by getting between Sunnis and Shias who have been fighting for 1300 years..."


Andy RichterAndy Richter: Conan's former sidekick just cannot catch a break in primetime. With NBC chopping "Andy Barker P.I.," he's got another one to add a trash heap, which includes "Quintuplets" and "Andy Richter Controls the Universe." What really stings in this case is that Conan co-created the show with Richter and threw all of his weight behind it at the Television Critics Association Winter Press Tour. "I feel like this is the best primetime work I have ever done," said Richter at the time. But when Richter saw that NBC was willing to put all six episodes up on the Internet before they had aired, it must have felt about as good as reading the reviews for his Olsen twins flick "New York Minute."


Michael Rapaport Michael Rapaport: Always a fun guest on "The Best Damn Sports Show Period," this guy's sitcom "The War at Home" was moved around willy-nilly for two years by Fox, eventually winding up in the death slot of 7:30 PM Sundays. And even though Rapaport has another TV pilot cooking over at CBS called "Fugly," he still sounded pissed when he sent out a pre-emptive MySpace bulletin last weekend, confirming the cancellation of his family comedy. It was definitely in-your-face entertainment ala "Married with Children," but one suspects that if Simon Cowell had been cast as the nosy neighbor, it would have survived.


Aaron Sorkin Aaron Sorkin: In the sketch show, coin-flip sweepstakes, Sorkin's low-rated "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip" lost out on Monday to the scandal-plagued "30 Rock." Sorkin fans everywhere are still in mourning, bemoaning the fact that a new bionic woman has been favored by the Peacock over unabashedly adult entertainment. But after a hiatus revamp failed to win viewers with more romance, this very expensive failure will now get to play out the string on Thursdays. Still, Sorkin has what no others in TV land have: the ability to cry all the way to the Tom Hanks-Julia Roberts-Mike Nichols bank (the stars and director of the upcoming Sorkin-scripted feature film, "Charlie Wilson's War").

Tags: aaron sorkin, AaronSorkin, andy richter, AndyRichter, Conan Obrian, ConanObrian, donald logue, DonaldLogue, michael rapaport, MichaelRapaport, paul higgis, PaulHiggis, studio 60, Studio60

Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 2) Previous 15 Comments

16. Yes,Yes,Yes...NBC dropped more than the ball on this show...if they look at the ratings and actually read between the lines the show was watche even after they cancelled it. In this media based world we live in there is more than just televisions to watch a program and it should show on the ratings that nielsen puts out. NBC doesnt believe in the nielsen ratings which is there option but Nielsen does have other ways to get the rating besides the television...Netrating what is being viewd on the computer. NBC should step up to the plate and make the move to the future...Change how tv is viewed and keep it on the computer...The viewing may change how things work and how ratings are read...So YES...They did drop the ball...but maybe they or another NETWORK will pick it up and run with it...Lets hope so......

Posted at 2:29PM on May 22nd 2007 by rick

17. The Black Donnellys was and still is an amazing show. NBC was narrow minded and short sighted in cancelling it. You can't blame Paul Haggis for NBC's mistake. I have faith that some other network will see the potential this show has and pick it up for a second season.

It's such a shame when good tv gets trampled by bad decisions.

Posted at 10:41PM on May 22nd 2007 by Jerry

18. Paul Haggis did a wonderful job with The Black Donnellys. It was well written, produced and acted. NBC's decision to cancel it is just another nail in their coffin of ratings and the reason they will continue to trail behind all the other networks.

I'm adding my hope with the others that this fantastic show will get the recognition it deserves and be signed for a second season on a network that will appreciate it.

Posted at 3:32PM on May 23rd 2007 by Deana

19. Wow, it looks like the Donnelly fans came out to spam this article, all 18 of them. Sorry to burst your bubble, but YES the show sucked.

The brothers were way too stupid and inexperienced to pull any of this crap off and take over a part of NYC, plus they were such scumbags that you wanted them dead by the third episode, especially Jimmy. Add in a horrible narrator and bad plots, you get TBD. One hell of an awful show, worse than Studio 60 which had some good actors.

Any show that loses half of it's pilots audience in a matter of weeks deserves to be cancelled. NBC did the right job there. If only they can pick up better pilots the next time around.

Posted at 4:21PM on May 24th 2007 by Mike

20. Puh-leeze. The Black Donnely's sucked horribly. Who cares about a family of delinquints? I couldn't even get all the way through the pilot it was so awful. I'm especially angry because they canned the incredible Studio 60 for it. Of course, most of America isn't intelligent enough to get that show, so they had to fall back on (what else?) a violent Irish family. I blame the moronic American people who can't get enough of Jerry Springer and reality TV.

Posted at 5:24PM on May 24th 2007 by T-bar

21. Reply to T-Bar: So most of America isn't intelligent to get Studio 60, but one such as yourself who is intelligent enough to get it can't spell delinquent.

Puh-leeze.

Posted at 4:33PM on May 27th 2007 by Rob

22. To Mike........if the show was really that unwatchable as you say, how did you ever stay around until the third episode? Seriously, TBD is a great show with depth that you apparently haven't reached yet. It's ok, there has to be shallow people in the world too!

Posted at 5:11PM on May 27th 2007 by Jimmy

23. What a crock! Both respondents with negative feedback about TBD had spelling issues. "...half of it's pilots audience..." should be "...half of its pilot's audience..."

But I digress. THIS IS FRIGGIN PAUL HAGGIS!!!! CRASH, anyone??!! The writing was great, and I really hope the recent shake-up at NBC will result in this show coming back.

Posted at 3:16PM on May 31st 2007 by Bill

24. There are more than 18 Black Donnelly's fans---which is a miracle since it had either reality or teenage show lead-ins and was stuck in 24 hangover land at 10 pm on Mondays. We'll see how the DVD set sells. You never know. Too bad it was cancelled...but at least it wasn't another Friend's retread that had such predictable stereotypes and pathetic characters and writing as Studio 60. I for one am waiting on Goldcase to be put in the 10pm slot next year on Mondays. If it weren't for the Office and Earl, NBC would be dead.

Posted at 10:21PM on Jun 19th 2007 by JD

25. http://www.grain.hu/eso.htm
rainmaker

Posted at 6:05AM on Jun 4th 2007 by bíró zoltán

Previous 15 Comments